HMC
Earth and Environment
Community Wiki

User Tools

Site Tools

Trace:
wiki:m2.0

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
wiki:m2.0 [2023/11/06 17:50] – [1. Explanation of the Background and Benefits of the Recommendation] apoerschwiki:m2.0 [2025/05/26 09:19] (current) – [2. Possible alternative solutions] esoeding
Line 5: Line 5:
 =====Description===== =====Description=====
  
-[Status: Under development, Date: 2023-10-30, Version: 001] +[Status: Under development, Date: ~~LASTMOD~~, Version: 001] 
  
 =====Motivation for this Recommendation: ===== =====Motivation for this Recommendation: =====
  
  
-The Helmholtz Association is determined to make their data available according to the FAIR principles, thus making it findable, accessible, interoperable and reusable. In order to achieve interoperability of datasets among various data infrastructures (DIS) within the Helmholtz Association, a common and agreed procedure to refer to people within and across the DIS is needed.+The Helmholtz Association is determined to make their data available according to the FAIR principles, thus making it findable, accessible, interoperable and reusable. In order to achieve interoperability of datasets among various data infrastructures (DIS) within the Helmholtz Association, a common and agreed procedure to refer to the respective Helmholtz Centres (organisations) within and across the DIS is needed.
  
 In order to be able to uniquely and sustainably identify the responsibilities and the context of cooperation within data infrastructures and repositories in the Helmholtz Association, the referencing of the respective centre should in principle be carried out with a persistent identifier (PID). In order to be able to uniquely and sustainably identify the responsibilities and the context of cooperation within data infrastructures and repositories in the Helmholtz Association, the referencing of the respective centre should in principle be carried out with a persistent identifier (PID).
Line 22: Line 22:
  
  
-Binding Convention: +=====Binding Convention===== 
-^                         ^ mandatory  ^ conditional           ^ optional ^+|                         ^ mandatory  ^ conditional           ^ optional ^
 ^ Helmholtz FAIR Principle|            | mandatory if ROR is available|          | ^ Helmholtz FAIR Principle|            | mandatory if ROR is available|          |
  
Line 59: Line 59:
  
 __Current Use of ...__ __Current Use of ...__
 +
 +Over the recent years numerous repositories and initiatives have recommended the use of ROR. Among them e.g. Arbeitskreis Forschungsdatenmanagement (AK FDM) in Baden-Württemberg [1]
  
 __Motivation__ __Motivation__
Line 68: Line 70:
 The database can be accessed via the official website, an open API or as a downloadable database dump. All ROR identifiers and metadata are provided under the CC0 licence. The database can be accessed via the official website, an open API or as a downloadable database dump. All ROR identifiers and metadata are provided under the CC0 licence.
 ====2. Possible alternative solutions==== ====2. Possible alternative solutions====
 +
 +Several alternatives exist: 
 +
 +1. GRID (Global Research Identifier Database) [Deprecated, replaced by ROR]
 +
 +Status: No longer maintained, but still used in legacy systems.
 +
 +Scope: Global research institutions, similar to ROR.
 +
 +Use case: May be used if your system still relies on GRID identifiers, which are mapped to ROR in most cases.
 +
 +Note: Since ROR is a community-led continuation of GRID, migrating to ROR is generally encouraged.
 +
 +
 +2. ISNI (International Standard Name Identifier)
 +
 +Scope: Broad—covers not only research institutions but also other organizations and individuals involved in creative or intellectual work.
 +
 +Managed by: ISNI International Agency.
 +
 +Use case: Useful for linking to authority records in library or publishing systems (e.g., for institutions in MARC21 authority data).
 +
 +
 +3. National or Domain-Specific Authority Files
 +
 +Examples include:
 +
 +  * GND (Gemeinsame Normdatei) – German National Authority File.
 +
 +  * LCNAF – Library of Congress Name Authority File (U.S.).
 +
 +  * SUDOC – French academic institutions (Abes).
 +
 +Use case: Often used in library, archival, or bibliometric infrastructures.
 +
 +Limitation: Coverage and update frequency vary; may not be globally interoperable.
 +
 +4. Internal Institutional IDs
 +
 +Scope: Local or consortium-level identifiers for partner institutions or affiliates.
 +
 +Use case: When working within a closed or federated system (e.g., within Helmholtz or NFDI), organizations may assign internal codes or URIs.
 +
 +Caution: Not globally resolvable unless made publicly accessible.
  
 ====3. Consideration of the advantages and disadvantages of implementing the recommendation==== ====3. Consideration of the advantages and disadvantages of implementing the recommendation====
Line 75: Line 121:
  
 ====4. The Recommendation==== ====4. The Recommendation====
 +It is recommended that all data infrastructures and repositories of the Helmholtz Association use ROR to identify organizations to resources in data infrastructures wherever and whenever possible. 
  
-[Format: Wer! macht was! wo! wann! unter welchen Voraussetzungen!] +==== 5. Naming of communities that have already implemented the recommendation====
- +
-====5. Naming of communities that have already implemented the +
-recommendation====+
  
 ====6. Documentation of the test to validate correct implementation==== ====6. Documentation of the test to validate correct implementation====
Line 90: Line 134:
  
 ===References=== ===References===
 +
 +[1] Entwicklung in Baden-Württemberg: ORCID und ROR IDs als Standard für langfristige Personen- und Institutionen-Identifier[[https://bausteine-fdm.de/article/view/8272]]
  
 ===Relevant Community Recommendations=== ===Relevant Community Recommendations===
wiki/m2.0.1699293011.txt.gz · Last modified: by apoersch